Is The Customer Always Right? Exploring This Age-Old Business Maxim

Image of a woman doing support on laptop
Category icon
Clock icon
6 mins to read

The saying “the customer is always right” is one of the most well-known maxims in business. But is it actually true that customers are always in the right? This age-old expression has its roots in customer service psychology and continues to influence how companies interact with consumers today. Let's take a closer look at the meaning behind this famous phrase and examine whether customers are really always right.

What Does "The Customer Is Always Right" Mean?

The basic idea behind this maxim is that customers know what they want and it's a company's job to provide it. It prioritizes customer satisfaction above all else.

Some key implications of "the customer is always right":

  • Customer requests should be fulfilled without argument or pushback
  • Customer complaints should be resolved as quickly as possible
  • Customers should feel valued and respected during all interactions
  • The customer's perspective is given priority in interactions

This mindset emerged in the early 20th century as small mom-and-pop stores sought to compete with larger department stores. They used superior customer service as a competitive advantage. The maxim was a way to empower employees to keep customers happy.

Why Do Companies Embrace "The Customer Is Always Right"?

There are a few key reasons this motto has stood the test of time:

  • Increased sales and profits - Keeping customers happy typically translates to more sales and repeat business over the long-term.
  • Brand reputation - Good customer service and resolving complaints helps build a positive brand image and reputation.
  • Competitive advantage - Outstanding service can differentiate a company from competitors.
  • Customer loyalty - Making customers feel valued fosters brand loyalty and long-term relationships.

Are Customers Really "Always Right"?

While the spirit behind this motto made sense in early retail, a debate has emerged around whether it still applies in the modern world. Some limitations have become clear:

Some Customer Demands Are Unreasonable

Occasionally customers make unreasonable demands that companies simply cannot or should not fulfill. For example:

  • Requesting a partial refund on a years-old product
  • Asking for unlimited free returns/exchanges
  • Wanting exceptions that violate company policy or ethics

Strictly adhering to "the customer is always right" would require meeting these demands. But most companies recognize there are certain limits.

It Can Enable Abusive Customer Behavior

Some "customers" abuse this mindset, knowing that companies feel obligated to please them. Verbally abusing staff, making unreasonable demands, and outright scamming are examples of bad faith behavior enabled by an overly rigid interpretation of this maxim.

Other Stakeholders Matter Too

While customers are important, companies also have responsibilities to employees, shareholders, and the greater public. Catering to customers at the expense of these other groups is short-sighted. A more balanced approach is optimal.

It Discourages Critical Feedback

Customers do not have all the information about how a business operates. Their feedback can be short-sighted or fail to grasp certain complexities. Dismissing critical customer feedback out of hand is not constructive.

Finding The Right Balance

So where does this leave the age-old motto? Most experts agree that "the customer is always right" retains merit as an ideal to aspire to, but cannot be followed absolutely in all cases. The right approach is balancing multiple stakeholder needs.

Key Strategies To Balance Different Interests:

  • Empower employees - Trust staff to use their best judgment in difficult situations.
  • Set reasonable policies - Make policies clear upfront so customers know what to expect.
  • Respond with empathy - Even if a request can't be fulfilled, validate the customer's perspective.
  • Reward loyalty - Offer perks and discounts to valuable long-term customers when possible.
  • Collect feedback - Gather customer insights through surveys and reviews.
  • Admit mistakes - When the company is clearly in the wrong, accept responsibility.

While the customer may not literally always be right, keeping their best interests in mind remains smart business. As management guru Peter Drucker put it: “The purpose of a business is to create and keep a customer.” The spirit of this age-old maxim lives on.

Key Takeaways: Is The Customer Really Always Right?

  • "The customer is always right" is a famous business motto emphasizing customer satisfaction.
  • This mindset helps increase sales, build loyalty, and boost brand reputation.
  • But unreasonable demands, abuse, and competing priorities reveal limitations.
  • Companies need to balance customer interests with other stakeholders.
  • Strategies like empowering staff, defining policies, and gathering feedback help strike the right balance.
  • The spirit of this maxim remains relevant, even if the letter does not always apply.

So while customers may not be unilaterally "right" 100% of the time, keeping their viewpoint central remains wise. Thoughtful policies, empowered employees, and a focus on mutual satisfaction help companies embody this age-old motto in an evolving business landscape.

How does your organization interpret this famous saying?

Experience magic with JustReply.

Get Started
From 300+ Customer Reviews
Green checkmark icon
Easily customised and edited
Green checkmark icon
Build to industry leading standards
Green checkmark icon
99.9% cheaper than alternatives